Sending emails to existing customers without consent: is it GDPR-compliant?

In email marketing, the double opt-in process ensures that senders have every subscriber’s explicit consent to receive newsletters. This consent is necessary to demonstrate in court, in the event of a dispute, that emails were sent in compliance with the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG) and to meet the accountability requirements of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). But what about existing customers? Can you contact them by email without double opt-in consent and still comply with the GDPR?
1. The double opt-in process and the GDPR
With the double opt-in process, prospective subscribers receive a confirmation email after signing up for a newsletter. They must click the link provided in that email to complete their subscription to your newsletter. The process allows you, as the sender, to demonstrate that every recipient has given explicit consent to receive your newsletters. In the event of a court dispute, this consent is necessary to show that the emails were not sent against the recipients’ wishes and therefore do not breach the GDPR.
Whether a newsletter is sent in a GDPR-compliant manner therefore depends primarily on the recipients’ consent, rather than on the process used to sign up for the newsletter. The General Data Protection Regulation does not itself make the double opt-in method a legal requirement. However, Article 7 of the GDPR defines requirements for obtaining this type of consent, and these should be observed.
Nevertheless, double opt-in is the easiest way for you to obtain recipients’ consent in a structured manner. It also makes it straightforward to provide evidence of consent, as required by the GDPR’s accountability principle, in the event of a court dispute. With rapidmail’s email marketing tool, for example, the time at which a recipient clicks the link in the double opt-in confirmation email is automatically saved in your account and can be retrieved at any time.
By contrast, the single opt-in process (signing up without clicking a second time in a confirmation email) makes it almost impossible to provide evidence of a recipient’s explicit consent. Any website user could enter someone else’s email address and subscribe that person to the newsletter. Single opt-in alone is therefore not sufficient to ensure GDPR-compliant email marketing.
2. Current legal position on sending GDPR-compliant emails to existing customers
As the saying goes, every rule has an exception. There is also an exception to the requirement for recipients’ consent when newsletters are sent to existing B2B customers: under certain conditions, you do not need to obtain separate consent for advertising (for example, through a double opt-in process) to send newsletters to existing B2B customers.
When are B2B newsletter recipients considered existing customers?
For newsletter recipients to qualify as your existing customers and for the exception described above to apply, the recipients must:
- have already purchased an item from you, either in a shop or online, or used a service you offer.
- have completed the purchase in full. This excludes people who abandoned their shopping basket and prospective customers who have created an account but have not yet purchased anything.
- have made a purchase no more than one year ago.
The rapidmail newsletter
Tips, ideas and news about email marketing, straight to your inbox.
When can I legally send newsletters to existing B2B customers without double opt-in consent?
When considering whether you can legally send newsletters to existing customers, the key legislation is not so much the GDPR as the German Act against Unfair Competition, specifically Section 7(3) UWG. Under the UWG, advertising to existing customers by email, often also referred to as “direct marketing”, is permitted without additional consent if all of the following conditions are met:
- Customers provided their email address when purchasing the relevant goods or services: please note that the entire purchase process must have been completed.
- The newsletters contain advertising only for similar products or services: every item presented to customers in the newsletter must serve the same purpose, such as other models or newer versions, or meet the same need, such as accessories for the purchased item, as the product they previously purchased.
- Your customers have not expressly objected to receiving your newsletters.
- At the time of purchase, your existing customers must have been informed that they can object to receiving newsletters or advertising emails at any time and free of charge, as well as how they can do so. This is easy to implement by informing customers during the purchase process, for example directly below the email address field, how their email addresses will be used and how they can exercise their right to object. You could use the following notice:
“Unless you have objected, we will use your email address to send advertising for similar goods or services. You may object to this use of your contact address at any time by emailing newsletter@yourcompany.com or clicking the unsubscribe link in our advertising emails. You will not incur any costs other than the transmission costs at the basic rate.”
If all four conditions are met, you may contact your existing B2B customers by newsletter without obtaining separate consent and without breaching the GDPR or the UWG. Of course, you must also comply with all other legal requirements for sending newsletters and data protection requirements for email marketing when contacting existing customers.
💡 rapidtip
This does NOT apply to B2C customers. You must ALWAYS obtain their double opt-in consent.
3. Conclusion: do newsletters to existing customers without explicit consent breach the GDPR?
When sending newsletters to existing customers, all four conditions described above must be met at the same time before you can send them advertising emails without obtaining separate double opt-in consent. If this is the case, a newsletter to existing customers without explicit consent objectively constitutes neither a breach of the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG) nor a breach of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
However, the legal boundaries are not always clearly defined and can therefore be difficult to interpret. For example, you would have to decide on a case-by-case basis whether a product advertised in a newsletter is genuinely “similar” to an item the person has already purchased. Only then may you email them without consent. It is difficult to predict whether the competent court would agree with your assessment in the event of a dispute. As this concerns the protection of personal data, the rules are often interpreted very strictly in practice.
For this reason, we expressly advise all newsletter senders to use email marketing only where double opt-in consent has been obtained, regardless of whether the recipients are newsletter subscribers or existing customers. This is the safest approach in every case.
When you use rapidmail as your email marketing tool, every new sign-up through the newsletter sign-up form on your website automatically triggers a double opt-in confirmation email to the new subscriber. This ensures that, as the sender, you can easily demonstrate in the event of a legal dispute that you have the necessary consent for every contact. We also permit emails to be sent only to email addresses for which a customer relationship can be demonstrated. This enables us to provide 100% GDPR-compliant email marketing through our software.
Send GDPR-compliant emails now
4. Bonus: download our free checklist for GDPR-compliant newsletter marketing

You now know which conditions apply when sending newsletters to existing customers, and why we strongly recommend sending newsletters only where double opt-in consent has been obtained. However, there are several other rules you must follow to ensure that your newsletter marketing is 100% GDPR-compliant.
To make the complex subject of data protection as simple and straightforward as possible, we have created an interactive data protection checklist for newsletters. It shows you exactly which requirements you need to follow and lets you check off those you have already implemented successfully.
Enjoy! ✅